Aj's Pizza Butler Menu

Aj's Pizza Butler menu gallery

From a reviewer’s perspective, the menu at Aj's Pizza Butler at 12 Main St, Butler, NJ, feels like a well-rounded celebration of classic Italian-American comfort food, thoughtfully organized to satisfy both everyday cravings and group dining needs. The weekly combo specials set the tone for value and variety, with highlights like the Pizza Combo Special featuring Large Cheese Pizza, Large Caesar Salad, and 2L Soda, or the hearty Pasta Combo Special built around Pasta W/ Vodka Sauce & Chicken. Each weekday brings something different, from Tuesday’s satisfying L Cheese Pizza + Chicken Fingers w/ Fries + 2L Soda to Wednesday’s more traditional Italian offerings such as Chicken Parmigiana + L Caesar Salad + 2L Soda and Eggplant Rollatini Appetizer + L Meatball Parm Sub + 2L Soda.

Pizza lovers are clearly at home here. Large Cheese Pizza Pie anchors Thursday Pizza Day, while the specialty lineup-Cheese Pizza, 16" Sicilian Pizza, 16" Grandma Pizza, Chicken Vodka Pizza, and Tangy BBQ Chicken Pizza-adds depth and personality. The option for Pizza Slice, Sicilian Slice, White Slice, Chicken Slice, or Chicken Francese Slice, along with specialty crusts like 10" Gluten Free Pizza and 10" Cauliflower Pizza Crust, makes the pizza menu flexible and inclusive.

Beyond pizza, the main menu is impressively extensive. Starters such as Mac & Cheese, Mac & Cheese W/ Bacon, Broccoli Cheddar Bites, and Eggplant Rollatini (2) lead naturally into paninis like Prosciutto Panini or Grilled Chicken Pesto Panini, fresh salads, wraps, cold and hot subs, and specialty subs including Chicken Francese Specialty Sub and Hot Roast Beef Specialty Sub. Pasta dishes range from Pasta W Marinara Sauce to Pasta Garlic & Oil, while dinner entrées cover Chicken Parmigiana, Veal Marsala, and seafood favorites like Shrimp Scampi.

The menu finishes strong with comfort classics such as Cheeseburger, Pizza Burger, Cheese Calzone, Cheese Stromboli, soups, desserts like Cannoli, Cheesecake, and Zeppoles (12), plus an extensive beverage selection from Mexican Coke to Vitamin Water XXX. Overall, Aj’s Pizza Butler delivers a comprehensive, crowd-pleasing menu that confidently wraps up everything you’d expect from a neighborhood Italian pizzeria-and then some.